A flurry of Egyptian television commercials for medical charities featuring miserable and suffering children children-not actors- has elicited disgust in some quarters.
The advertisement goes like this: three-year-old Asmaa looks pale and upset then suddenly bursts into tears. Two hands appear and harshly dry her tears, she smiles again, and then melodramatic music cues simple words written on the screen: “illness, cancer, pain and hope.”
This is one of the many new advertisements in Egyptportrayingsuffering children in order to raise money for health charities this month. As the fasting month of Ramadan comes to an end, and Eidapproaches, this is the main season for charitable giving and hospitals are competing for people to donate money or pay their religious dues.
Another advertisement features sick children, each saying, “You can help me,” while waving a finger at the viewer. A third advertisement shows children praying and reading the Quran, with the message, “Keep them in your prayers and donate what you can.”
These advertisements leave some viewers upset, others shocked, angry or neutral.However, is it ethical to use ill and suffering children in charity advertisements? How far can one go?
“Some of these advertisements should be banned by law. The advertisement where they make the baby cry, and mercilessly dry her tears while pulling her skin so that we see her red eyelids, now that is ruthless,” says Ferial Ahmed, 50, while buying medicine from a pharmacy in the upscale neighborhood of Muhandiseen.
AmiraWagdy, a pharmacist, intervenes: “Yes, the advertisement may not be ethical, but some people will not donate unless they are cruelly faced with people’s suffering.” Wagdy, 34, wishes that everyone paid their “dues” without being pushed and without using the suffering of children, who “not only suffer in real life, but also have to sell their suffering on camera.”
HanyHelal of the Egyptian Children’s Rights Centre believes that using children in charity advertisements is a clear form of child abuse. “Using children to raise money is illegal, and unacceptable. The state should provide every child with free and proper healthcare. No child should beg for treatment,” he told Ahram Online.
However, the state provides neither children nor adults with free or proper healthcare. The latest government studies show that 25 percentof Egypt’s children suffer from malnutrition-related diseases. In addition, Egypt comes in 80th in the world for mortality rates in children underfive-years-old.
Health services form only five percent of the current annual state budget.
As soon as one steps into Egypt’s only children’s cancer hospital, called 57357, the terrible facts come to life. Visibly ill and pale children in wheelchairs fill the large reception area, the corridors, the lifts and the toilets. Countless mothers carry hairless babies. The hospital only accepts one third of children with cancer in Egypt. Although it is free of charge there are long lines of children waiting to be admitted. The hospital has the only radiotherapy and chemotherapy equipment in Egypt, so both children and adults come for treatment.
The hospital is responsible for one of the much-debated advertisements showingsuffering children on camera.
Wahba believes that ethically there is no problem in using suffering children in charity advertisements. “We are showing the reality, and we only do the ad with consent of the child and the family. We don’t use models; children with cancer are not happy children, they are pale, hairless and suffering,” said Wahba, referring to the recent ad of the crying child.
She continuesthat the hospital has its own media unit that produces the advertisements. “The board unanimously agreed on this advertisement. The initial storyboard was different. Asmaa was supposed to talk about her illness and her suffering, but she surprised us all with her crying, so we changed the script,” said Wahba.
On a psychological level
Is there an emotional or physical burden that Asmaa could be suffering from explaining her tears on camera?
According to Mohamed Nasr El-Din, a psychiatrist at Cairo University, she could be crying from pain or anxiety. He also adds that there are both positive and negative sides to children appearing in advertisements. “On the positive side, they are sharing their experiences and creating awareness in society. But on the negative side they are ‘promoting’ their own illness, which may be considered a stigma,” said Nasr El-Din, who also works at 57357 Hospital.
Helal, the children’s rights activist, repeats that having children appear in charity advertisements goesagainst human dignity and that no child should be shown on their sick bed begging for help. “Egypt signed the Convention on the Rights of the Child, which states that children’s dignity should be protected. The annual state health budget should bear in mind the number of ill children and provide them with the necessary healthcare. Civil society and charities should work on improving the already existing services, but not create them.”
Corporate responsibility or marketing?
ForAlia Arafa, a development expert, using suffering children in advertisements is definitely ethical. “It is shocking, just like war photos. Reality is shocking. If it wasn’t for the photos we see from the Palestinian Intifada, Israel wouldn’t have been scandalized,” said Arafa.
For Arafa, the question is not whether it is ethical or not; the question is about the intention behind the advertisement. “Some of thecompaniesperceive corporate social responsibility as part of their marketing agenda. They donate money not for the cause, but to write their names on it. No real development results, because they either don’t have the know-how or don’t support long-term initiatives,” Arafa told Ahram Online.
At the office of the MagdyYacoub Heart Surgery Charity in Zamalek, there are only three employees. Miral El-Zalabany, the assistant executive directoranswers AhramOnline’s questions in the middle of dozens of phone calls. MagdyYaqoub Hospital was part of another controversial advertisement in which the child doesn’t cry or beg for help, but rather smiles and says, “I want to live,” in answer to the question, “What do you want?” Other healthy children answer, “I want many toys,” “I want long hair,” “I want to eat koshary [an Egyptian dish of rice, lentils and chickpeas].”
The renowned Egyptian heart surgeon, MagdyYacoub, who is based in the UK, followed his dream of building a charity hospital in Aswan, Upper Egypt, for children with heart problems. He did not think 1000 children a day would crowd the hospital for heart surgeries that cost around $5000 each. Until recently, the hospital did not use children in their advertisements. El-Zalabany admits she had difficulty convincing the ethics committee at the Yacoub institution. “They said no children’s names or photos. But I pushed for it. I have a bigger aim: to find the money for thousands of children whoneedheart surgeries, or else they will die,” she said.
“The advertisement was successful, and even though the production is a gift, we pay for air time. It was risky, but thank God, it was very successful. For every pound I spent I got back 17 to 25 pounds,” El-Zalabany added.
El-Zalabany agrees that using children in advertisements should be kept to a minimum. She admitsthat the advertisingindustry needs some time to evolve, to use creative imagery rather than the classic images they are used to. “After all, these are people who sell butter and shampoo; that is their expertise. They play it safe. No one wants to change,” said El-Zalabany, whose advertisement is less controversial than others using children. At least the children look happy and healthy, and the girl appearing in the advertisement had heart surgery and is now healthy.
How much money?
Ahram Online could not get an exact number, but charities usually pay between 30 to 50 percent of the cost price of airtime.
As for the actual production of the advertisement, in some cases the organizationdoes its own production, like 57357, while some are gifted the production costs, like SaadiGohar, who approached MagdyYacoub Hospital and produces their advertisements free of charge. Others have to pay companies for their advertisements.
Whether using children in advertisements is ethical or not, stigmatizing or not, the ugly fact remains that thousands of children in Egypt are suffering and do not receive adequate healthcare.
02 Mar 2013